- Puzzles
- Eleven in the main story and one in Born from a Wish, per one guide.
- Random
- Several codes change on every run, so no guide can give them; this page says how to read them.
- Riddle Level
- Easy, Normal, Hard and the hidden Extra change the clue and often the answer.
- Optional
- The apartment safe and the hospital's Trick or Treat chest can be skipped.
How Riddle Level changes the puzzles
Answers that never change
| Puzzle | Where | Easy | Normal | Hard | Extra |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grandfather clock | Wood Side Apartments | Set the hands to 9:10 | 9:10 | 9:10 | 9:10 |
| Old coin desk (slots left to right) | Blue Creek Apartments, room 105 | Old Man, empty, Snake, empty, Prisoner | Empty, Old Man, Prisoner, empty, Snake | Empty, Old Man, empty, Snake, Prisoner | Old Man, empty, Snake, Prisoner, empty |
| Third-floor patient wing keypad | Brookhaven Hospital | 7335 | 7335 | 1328 | 1328 |
| Free the innocent man | Labyrinth | Kidnapper | Arsonist | Counterfeiter | Thief |
| Music boxes (left to right) | Lakeview Hotel | Any box in any slot | Cinderella, Snow White, Little Mermaid | Cinderella, Little Mermaid, Snow White | Same as Hard |
Notes on those answers
- Coin desk: three guides give the same four orders. There are only three coins (Old Man, Snake and Prisoner); two of the five slots always stay empty. The desk gives the Lyne House Key, which opens room 209.
- Keypad: two guides give both codes. On Hard and Extra the whiteboard clue speaks of the letter T, and 1328 traces a T on the keypad.
- Free the innocent man: two guides give the four answers. Find the innocent man among the hanged corpses, then pull the rope in the same position in the room of nooses.
- Music boxes: two guides say the clue is the same on Hard and Extra, and both give the two orders above.
- Grandfather clock: two guides give 9:10. One adds that you need the Clock Key; the other, that once the time is right James can push the clock aside.
Codes that change every run
Apartment safe (optional)
Two guides explain it. Read the code from the note, then turn the dial: any direction to the first number, right to the second, left to the third, right to the fourth. On Hard some numbers are Roman numerals; on Extra letters stand in for numbers above 9, counting a as 10, b as 11 and so on.
The Louise box (hospital)
One guide: combine the two keys and use them, then enter the code from the typewriter's carbon paper on the button lock and the code written in blood on the wall on the dial lock.
Historical Society keypad
One guide: two or three keys light up. The code uses only those digits, so try the few possible orders.
Box of faces (Labyrinth)
Two guides say an upside-down face with yellow eyes works on Easy and Normal; one guide adds the upside-down face with green eyes. On Hard and Extra both say the answer varies: one guide says to turn the cube until two doorways in the metal room line up.
Hotel briefcase
One guide: use the Thinner from the basement elevator on the photo on the bed to wipe off the ink and reveal the code.
Small puzzles and Born from a Wish
- Trick or Treat chest (hospital, optional): one guide gives the buttons as 3, 1, 3.
- Gravestone in the Baldwin Mansion (Born from a Wish): one guide says to insert the White and Black boards as they are, and the Red board turned 90 degrees to the left.